Adler Firm, PLLC
Free Consultation - Call 24/7

The many layers of a SSDI appeal (Cont.)

Last time, we discussed the appeals process for a Social Security disability claim. A recent case demonstrates how this process can work. A woman's application for SSD benefits was denied. She appealed and the ALJ denied her claim. Her appeal of the ALJ's decision was denied by the Appeals Council, and so the woman appealed to a federal court.

A federal magistrate judge found the ALJ failed to provide support for the denial in the opinion and she recommended sending the case back to SSA to remedy this failure. SSA objected and they appealed the case to a U.S. District Court judge. She ruled against SSA and agreed with the magistrate judge. She ordered the case be returned to ALJ for additional findings. 

In this case, the ALJ noted that while the medical evidence seemed to support the disability claim, the worker's claim that she suffered fatigue and had difficulty with the pace of work and concentrating on an activity, lacked credibility.

The District Court judge found the ALJ's hypothetical for the vocational expert who testified was flawed and did not qualify as substantial evidence for denying the claim. This was because the opinion did not adequately explain the credibility issue relating to each of her symptoms, and which elements of her claim lacked credibility.

The worker now has to await the new ruling from the ALJ, and she could still be denied her claim. For anyone who believes SSD benefits are easy to obtain, this case should remind them that the appeals process can be long and difficult and persistence is necessary.

Source:, "Benefits dispute remanded to Social Security Commissioner's Office," Nicholas Malfitano, July 13, 2015

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Request A Free Consultation

Representing Michigan injured workers since 1979.

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Traverse City Office
13561 S West Bay Shore Drive
Suite 301
Traverse City, MI 49684

Toll Free: 888-873-7173
Fax: 231-943-2299
Map & Directions

Farmington Hills Office
30300 Northwestern Highway
Suite 304
Farmington Hills, MI 48334

Map & Directions

Adler Firm, PLLC